Do you ever think about an interaction you had 5 years ago? Our memories can haunt us. Instead of looking forward, we tend to get fixated on things that happened in the past and how we could have changed them. It’s time to stop. Ichiro Kishimi and Fumitake Koga, authors of THE COURAGE TO BE DISLIKED, share how to live life without being controlled by the past through a hypothetical conversation between a philosopher and a young person…
Philosopher: How am I being nihilistic?
Youth: Think about it. Simply put, you deny human emotion. You say that emotions are nothing more than tools, that they’re just the means for achieving goals. But listen. If you deny emotion, you’re upholding a view that tries to deny our humanity, too. Because it’s our emotions, and the fact that we are swayed by all sorts of feelings, that make us human. If emotions are denied, humans will be nothing more than poor excuses for machines. If that isn’t nihilism, then what is?
Philosopher: I am not denying that emotion exists. Everyone has emotions. That goes without saying. But if you are going to tell me that people are beings who can’t resist emotion, I’d argue against that. Adlerian psychology is a form of thought, a philosophy that is diametrically opposed to nihilism. We are not controlled by emotion. In this sense, while it shows that people are not controlled by emotion, additionally it shows that we are not controlled by the past.
Youth: So people are not controlled either by emotion or the past?
Philosopher: Okay, for example, suppose there is someone whose parents had divorced in his past. Isn’t this something objective, the same as the well water that is always sixty degrees? But then, does that divorce feel cold or does it feel warm? So this is a “now” thing, a subjective thing. Regardless of what may have happened in the past, it is the meaning that is attributed to it that determines the way someone’s present will be.
Youth: The question isn’t “What happened?” but “How was it resolved?”
Philosopher: Exactly. We can’t go back to the past in a time machine. We can’t turn back the hands of time. If you end up staying in etiology, you will be bound by the past and never be able to find happiness.
Youth: That’s right! We can’t change the past, and that’s precisely why life is so hard.
Philosopher: Life isn’t just hard. If the past determined everything and couldn’t be changed, we who are living today would no longer be able to take effective steps forward in our lives. What would happen as a result? We would end up with the kind of nihilism and pessimism that loses hope in the world and gives up on life. The Freudian etiology that is typified by the trauma argument is determinism in a different form, and it is the road to nihilism. Are you going to accept values like that?
Youth: I don’t want to accept them, but the past is so powerful.
Philosopher: Think of the possibilities. If one assumes that people are beings who can change, a set of values based on etiology becomes untenable, and one is compelled to take the position of teleology as a matter of course.
Youth: So you are saying that one should always take the “people can change” premise?
Philosopher: Of course. And please understand, it is Freudian etiology that denies our free will and treats humans like machines.
Don’t let the past get you down. Here are 13 things to look forward to.